| |
The significance of timber and wood in the Alps
Forum Alpinum 2002 Workshop Biodiversity and
Agriculture
September 26, 2002, Alpbach (Tyrol, Austria)
Ian C. Meerkamp van Embden
Abstract.
No other material displays the true character of a sustainable resource
more convincingly than wood. Forestry and modern wood technology, therefor,
deserve high priority in the development of mountain regions. As a
renewable, natural product wood presents an impressive spectrum of unique
properties. Its application as universal construction material and energy
supplier offers a tremendous economic, ecological and social potential.
Yet, forest growth by far exceeds wood use in alpine countries such as
Austria, Switzerland the Bavarian Alps or Slovenia. This paper focuses on
innovative wood use as construction material in alpine regions. The
examples, however, can only reflect a small fraction of the considerable
and still not fully appreciated potential of wood in sustainable
development.
1.The economic and social significance of wood in
alpine regions.
Wood has an enormous economic and social
significance for European mountain regions , as illustrated by the
Austrian example:
- Wood
is Austria´s most important export product. In 1996, Austrian wood
exports represented roughly 4 ½ Billion €.
- 7000
energy centres in Austria utilise wood as an energy resource,
generating 22. 000 jobs for the installation, use and maintenance of
thermal power stations, covering an estimated 10 % of Austria´s
energy requirements
- A
significant part of Austrian Economy relies on medium and small size
companies engaged in such fields as logging, wood building and
construction, wood furniture, or the pulp and paper industry. The same
accounts for other countries with large forested alpine areas such as
in Switzerland, Italy, Germany, France or Slovenia.
2.
The ecological significance of wood.
The tremendous significance of our forests has fortunately been recognised
in European alpine countries, Their vital function as filters for clean
air, for the protection of water reserves and balance, their contribution
to the prevention of erosion, landslides, avalanches, rock falls or
inundation, and, last but not least, their contribution as habitat for
species and securing biodiversity is self explanatory and not subject of
this paper. As far as wood itself is concerned, three ecologically
relevant aspects should be kept in mind:
- Even
though the Integrated CO2-balance of wood still leaves some room to
scientific dispute, it can be maintained that wood as a renewable raw
material is in essence CO2-neutral. The wooden Roof of the Expo 2001
pavilion (now a protected wood monument) in Hannover stores 1.200 tons
of CO2 for the next century
- Wood
can easily be recycled or alternatively, it can finally be used as a
valuable source of energy.
- Wood
growth is tremendous: In Austrian forests it amounts to 1 cubic metre
per second, (in Switzerland for comparison 0,3 cubic metres per
second)!
3.
Problems and drawbacks impeding wood use.
Notwithstanding excellent prerequisites as a source of highly qualified
technical material wood has to cope with considerable handicaps:
- European
forest volume increase is higher than the increase in domestic wood
utilisation. Forested Surface in Europe has gone up from 175 million
ha (1960) to above 200 million ha at present. Only 70 % of wood growth
increase is used in Austria, and not more than 60 % in the rest of
Europe.
- Within
the quantities used, the predominant part of wood is utilised for low
priced applications and only offers a very modest added value.
- Despite
considerable innovative progress achieved in wood application
technology and particularly in technical construction, companies
involved in large scale wood construction, wood bridge building,
private wood house dwellings or other applications still deplore
considerable prejudice against the utilisation of wood as an
alternative to brick, steel, concrete or plastic.
- The
situation described is similar in practically all alpine countries.
What are the
reasons responsible for such a development, and what can be done against
it? To generate appropriate answers, ALPENFORUM carried out an inquiry
last year, providing interesting answers and viewpoints to the questions
posed. It is, however, not the purpose of this paper to elaborate on
details of this survey. One essential conclusion however should be stated
at this point: Public opinion clearly reflects a remarkable deficit in
proper judgement concerning the merits and shortcomings of wood as
construction material as compared to brick, concrete, steel or plastic.
Fire hazard attributed to wood, for instance, is generally overestimated.
Similar prejudice accounts for durability and a number of other
performance parameters. On the other hand, existing shortcomings of wood
constructions, such as unsatisfactory wind tightness or humidity diffusion,
may frequently be overlooked.
This situation
given, intelligent marketing strategies based on sound information and
communication are paramount for a better public appreciation of wood use.
The results of our personal interviews signal heavy shortcomings in this
respect. Though considerable efforts are presently made to alleviate the
problems involved, there remains a lot more to be done. It is interesting
to note that the Austrian Delphi-Report, when elaborating on the
innovative use of wood and its perspectives, arrives at quite similar
conclusions.
4.
wood construction technology and innovative application
Our alpine ancestors have developed characteristic versions of wood
architecture and a sophisticated knowledge of wood construction and
engineering. Wood in alpine lifestyle played a key function. Dwellings,
barns, bridges, churches or even fire stations were built of wood, which
was considered as an easily accessible and highly satisfactory indigenous
resource. Centuries ago it was realised that wood should be cut when low
in water content, and properly dried prior to processing. Buildings made
of wood in this manner proved stable and stayed that way an amazingly long
time. Much of this knowledge, unfortunately, got lost in the course of the
last century. Concrete, steel or plastic more and more replaced wood.
Prejudice voiced claims wood to be less durable. This certainly has
something to do with more modern, less time consuming lumbering practises
and the increasing disregard of seemingly old fashioned forestry and age
old wood technology experience. More recently, however, a change of mind
can be observed. Wood is regaining popularity, almost lost experience is
revitalised. Modern pioneers in wood application are combining sound wood
experience with modern technical concepts, other construction materials
and sophisticated solutions
The key answer to
success in modern wood house construction is the combination of comatible
construction material, attractive architectural design, high quality and
functional performance . These are the essential prerequisites to generate
both market acceptance and added value required The following examples
present a small selection of such more recent developments.
4.1 "Massive
wood"
Modular construction elements and a high prefabrication status
characterise the predominant tendencies in modern wood building. The high
stability of such elements allows even multistorage construction. It has
become apparent that conventional blockwood construction does not meet
modern housing requirements satisfactorily, and upright housing, therefor,
has gained reputation.
One of the newer
developments in this context is the so called massive wood element
("Holz 100" ). The Thoma wood construction campany in its
Goldegg Research centre, developed a simple, yet ingenious system: Upright
wood posts are arranged in several layers and a compact manner without
interstitial space. A calculated screen of dry wood dowel pins treated
with natural casein glue penetrate the wood elements with great pressure.
The pins absorb residual moisture within their new location and swell,
irriversibly compounding the element parts. The final element corresponds
to a monophase structure, 100 % wood. Such elements are extremely
resistant against damage, mold or condensation. They are highly wind- and
waterproof, expel excellent thermal insulation- and sound attenuation
properties. The same accounts for protection against high frequency
radiation. This type of wood element is practically the only material able
to carry a multistorage house and at the same time achieve the insulation
values required for a .low-energy house (k-value 0,22 W/m²K) without the
aid of additional insulating layers. Massive elements for upright
construction do not generate condensation problems and are extremely
effective insulators with correspondingly high k-values. This can be
explained by imprisoned air cushions in the interior of the rough wood
structure.
Another feature of
such massive elements is their excellent flame retardant property.
Elements with 40 cm width can accomplish flame retardant properties above
F 90. After flaming for 150 minutes, the element has still regained its
full bearing strength. Collapse of ceilings, as observed with concrete,
never takes place with such wood elements. After 60 minutes temperature
exposure at 900 °C, the backside of this massive wood element displays a
temperature increase of merely 3 to 10° C, a value far better than the F
30 required . Anybody questioning the durability of such constructions
should remember that wooden Japanese temples are more than 2000 years old
and still perfectly intact!
An alternative
concept to achieve improved wood performance is the KLH-system. Wood
boards are positioned and glued crosswise, thus obtaining massive elements
that are easily assembled to larger wall or ceiling modules. Insulation
and stability is less favourable than obtained with wood elements as
described previously, but perform better than ordinary wood constructions.
The system allows for improved load distribution in every direction and
time saving assembly.
4.2.Room climate
Another important feature of wood dwellings is their (interior) room
climate. Massive elements perform very well because of their high
insulating value (10,0 - 0,1 W/m²K) combined with their high specific
density (400- 500 kg/m³) .
4.3 Security
When studying modern wood construction developments, an amazing spectrum
of innovative applications are encountered. Security is an example. The
Freisinger wood company in Tyrol developed a highly successful
anti-burglary system for its wood window panels. Essential features of
this system are: Strengthened, multiplied lock bolts, solid screw joints
for all fittings, reinforced glass panels, careful assembly. Freisinger´s
"Antiknack" window panels withstand rough handling with
pointweights up to 300 kilos, 80 kilo sandbag drops from 80 cm height,
professional burglary efforts with wedge gibs, screw drivers or pliers, (standard
test period 3 minutes). It is assumed that the occasional burglar will
then give up his efforts and possibly try his luck elsewhere.
4.4. Energy saving
Still another aspect concerns energy saving. So called low energy houses
do without separate heating systems under the windows. This is only
possible with heat transmission coefficients of such windows below 0,8 W/m²K.
Freisinger´s wood window system meets this requirement by using in its
window panel an inner layer responsible for the complete window function
itself, a middle, non carrying cork insulation layer and an exterior,
protective layer, which is easily removed by twisting, and can be either
repaired or exchanged whenever necessary. Windows in wood can display a
remarkably esthetic appearance . The exterior layer mentioned is made of
larch, pine or oak, all durable wood types that require little surface
treatment or none at all.
The so called solar
facade is another energy saving wood element. The module is mounted on a
post-bar construction. The range spacer between the exterior wood layer
and the post-bar is thermally separated and consists of a wood fibre
insulation and wood carrier. The glass pane weight is born by statically
calculated glass clips.
4.5. Protection
against electro smog
A technical development in Southern Germany (Baufritz wood company , Allgäu)
concentrates on wood dwellings protected against Electro-smog. Ubiquitous
cell phones, high voltage power lines, transformers, radar stations,
electric train ducts or mobile wireless facilities, all of these and many
others can generate radiation. Science, so far, is not in a position to
clearly assess the possible human health damage caused by electromagnetic
exposure. As protective or at least preventive measure, Baufritz developed
a panel of natural gypsum lined with a thin layer of carbon. These panels
can be installed against wooden walls or roofs and earthed. Measurements
at the German army´s university in Munich confirmed high frequency
radiation screening up to 94 %. Massive "Wood 100", as a matter
of fact, equally displays similar or even better screening values, as
found by recent measurements at the already mentioned institute in Munich.
5.
Final remarks
Wood innovation and architecture, design
and technical application is the pride of numerous developments. The
construction examples given illustrate the value of "niche"-services
in sustainable wood development and the marketing strategies required to
promote such a development. Wood compounds, wood houses or other wood
facilities are steadily gaining reputation
- The
community of Murau built the largest European wood bridge).
- Production
facilities in different regions of the Alps have been and are
constructed.
- Functional
premises such as fire houses have regained popularity.
- Modern,
well built wood houses promote the quality of life for an increasing
number op people.
- The
expansion of Health centres or solar facades .
This is encouraging.
If sustainable development is our choice, then by all means we should
support and promote the use and innovative application of wood.
St. Georgen ob Murau, Austria
Dr. Ian c. Meerkamp van Embden
Tel.: 0043-3537-20020
Fax: 0043-3537-20022
e-mail: ALPENFORUM@t-online.de
|